Become A Member | Forum | Profiles | Personals | Classifieds | See Who's Online ...
 
View Topic
  Message Boards : TV / Films / Books : View Topic : 1241 Posts, Page 82 of 83
  HomeNewNoticesHot TopicsPollsStatsBlogs Login / Register
 
Game Of Thrones - G.R.R.Martin
 
# 1216 : Tuesday 28-6-2016 @ 22:23
 
 
We actually don't know who Jon's dad is, it was hinted but not explicitly stated.
Reply
 
 Recent Message Board Topics
Sexy Suspenders
Newbie Seeks Advice
Silly Principles You Uphold
Typical (Non) Relationship Stuff, I Assume
Brexit
What Gaire Member Did You See?
Dead Thread 2017
Big Brother 2017
 
Hey! If you enjoy shooting the breeze with like-minded people, check out
our Message Boards
• Advice • Coming Out
• Computers • Current Affairs
• Discussion • Food & Drink
• Going Out • Humour
• Health • Music
• Newbies • Sexual Issues
# 1217 : Tuesday 28-6-2016 @ 22:34
 
 
Just finished watching it. Wow just wow!
Reply
 
# 1218 : Tuesday 28-6-2016 @ 22:47
 
 
Someone said :
We actually don't know who Jon's dad is, it was hinted but not explicitly stated.

We also don't know the mom explicitly, but it is.
Reply
 
# 1219 : Wednesday 29-6-2016 @ 02:30
 
 
Someone said :
We also don't know the mom explicitly, but it is.

No, No.
What I mean is, it is obvious that the show is telling us that Lyanna is the child's Mother and that the child is Jon, but what the whole world seems to be forgetting is we do not "hear" the name of the father, we only hear that it is someone that if found out, would lead to the baby being killed.
Now, yes it does make sense that the father is Rheagar, but there is absolutely no guarantee at all that Rheagar is Jon's father.
The father could be any number of characters, including characters not involved in the storyline per se. Also, considering the popularity of the theory, it seem almost futile to "mute" Lyanna's message to Ed if Rheagar was indeed the father (since that's the most obvious possibility anyways).

That is, unless there is either a good reason (narrativly), or good dramatic cause (again narrativly) to leave the question open. Indeed there may not be good 'dramatic cause' to leave the question open; Rheagar being Jon's father would be an excellent development in the story anyways, obvious or not, but there is definitely good reason to leave the question open; it is simply not practical to assume there wouldn't have been anyone else in contact with Lyanna during a part of the story we've only seen/heard so far from character word of mouth.
There might be any number of as-yet-divulged affairs, rapings and secret meetings back in the time of Lyanna and the gang, that no one told anybody else about thus far.
Reply
 
# 1220 : Wednesday 29-6-2016 @ 08:25
 
 
No, we pretty much know.
Reply
 
# 1221 : Wednesday 29-6-2016 @ 15:37
 
 
"No, we pretty much know" is literally the only stupid answer you can give to the statement "you don't know for certain"
Reply
 
# 1222 : Wednesday 29-6-2016 @ 17:57
 
 
But we do pretty much know *runs and hides*
Reply
 
# 1223 : Wednesday 29-6-2016 @ 18:08
 
 
Someone said :
But we do pretty much know *runs and hides*

You know nothing for certain Thomas Admin! But you do
Reply
 
# 1224 : Wednesday 29-6-2016 @ 19:42
 
 
We know for certain now because HBO have released an infographic confirming Jon Snows parents

http://www.makinggameofthrones.com/production-diary/got-connectio etc ...
Reply
 
# 1225 : Wednesday 29-6-2016 @ 19:43
 
 
Someone said :
"No, we pretty much know" is literally the only stupid answer you can give to the statement "you don't know for certain"

So she was kidnapped by Rhaegar so he could hide her away in that tower and rape her. We know this. It was said at different points through the series and then she has a baby. It doesn't take a genius to work out who the Dad is.
Reply
 
# 1226 : Wednesday 29-6-2016 @ 19:43
 
 
Someone said :
We know for certain now because HBO have released an infographic confirming Jon Snows parents

http://www.makinggameofthrones.com/production-diary/got-connectio etc ...

And this too!
Reply
 
# 1227 : Tuesday 11-7-2017 @ 18:45
 
 
Is anyone else super excited new season starts in 6 days!!!!!!
Reply
 
# 1228 : Tuesday 11-7-2017 @ 22:02
 
 
Someone said :
Is anyone else super excited new season starts in 6 days!!!!!!

(book nerd!) Meh. I AM excited but its tempered by the fact I'd prefer to be getting the craziness first in text form.
Reply
 
# 1229 : Wednesday 12-7-2017 @ 13:00
 
 
The books are far behind tv, don't understand why he never finished them.
Reply
 
# 1230 : Wednesday 12-7-2017 @ 13:38
 
 
Really looking forward to it.
Reply
 
First Prev 7677787980818283Next